WiserEarth Suggestions

Building a better WiserEarth together

A place for ideas and exchanges to happen. Please provide your feedback and suggestions to improve WiserEarth here.

GROUP DETAILS

Created: Feb 11, 2008

Updated: Nov 05, 2009

Membership: Open

Public

Created: May 18, 2009
Updated: May 26, 2009
Viewed: 472 times

Topic: Edit new comment and lose previous rating

Posts (1 - 3 of 3)

Sort by: Ascending | Descending
Login to Post a Reply.
Sm_avatar
Flag comment for removal
sicjedi 6 months ago

Here's a tricky bug. Steps to reproduce:

  1. Add a comment and rating for an article.
  2. Make another comment for the article.
  3. Edit (really edit, not just click "Edit") the comment and save the edit. (Do not adjust or touch your article rating.) [This step may need to be repeated.]
  4. Your original comment rating is gone! And the article is no longer rated by you anywhere.

I've seen this problem on multiple suggestion articles (and I'm sure I've really lost a few of my ratings). Here is one such article, though I restored my rating: http://www.wiserearth.org/article/238f4a13bb82fcacd58d5193d2b2a237
Sm_avatar
Flag comment for removal
bowo 6 months ago
Good catch!
Sm_avatar
Flag comment for removal
Honore 6 months ago
Interesting bug - I'm pretty sure in the past, ratings were retained after a comment was edited.  Must be something clearing out the rating upon an edit.  I'll put it on the bug list.  Thanks!
You do not have access to post to this record
1 to 3 of 3 Posts


Contributors to this Page

Sm_avatar
sicjedi
Sm_avatar
Honore
Sm_avatar
bowo