Wings for Wisdom, the Idea.
"Human history becomes more and more a race between education and catastrophe." (H.G. Wells)
"What a great treasure can be hidden in a small, selected library! A company of the wisest and the most deserving people from all the civilized countries of the world, for thousands of years, can make the results of their studies and their wisdom available to us. The thought which they might not even reveal to their best friends is written here in clear words for us, people from another century. Yes, we should be grateful for the best books, for the best spiritual achievements in our lives." (Ralph Waldo Emerson)
"Read the best books first, otherwise you'll find you do not have time." (Henry David Thoreau)
The what and why of Wings for Wisdom
The main goal of this group's activity is to set free the most important intellectual works of our time from the confinement of copyright. These are the kind of works that could vastly improve our understanding of ourselves and the world and guide our action to make it a better one. They can be books, movies, songs, or other forms of creative and enlightened endeavour. Why do we need to do so?
As H.G. Wells put it so succintly, time is running short, catastrophe is right before our very eyes more than it is before his. Our world needs a massive wake up call, soon, if not already too late. This can only be done if the voice of the wisest people on earth are heard and enacted upon by as many people as possible.
Unfortunately,
the distribution of wisdom in our world is confined in the straitjacket
of copyright. One must first get hold of the medium of wisdom, be it
books or DVDs, preferably by purchasing them so the authors and
publisher can have financial rewards for the work they've done. The
problem is, not enough amount of the medium is produced for
enlightening the largest number of people, and if there are enough of
it, not everyone can afford to buy one.
The work-around for
this problem, piracy, is not a respectable solution, and maybe, not
even a solution at all, since it could destroy the wisdom generation
and dissemination system of authors-publishers-distributors in the long
run.
Libraries and rental shops are ofcourse helpful in solving this problem, but not nearly enough. For example, Rachel Carson's Silent Spring, which kickstarted the environmental movement of our time may not be available at every library. This is not mentioning the fact that in many parts of developing countries and most part of poor countries, libraries don't even exist.
Recent attempts by search engine giants: Google, Microsoft and Yahoo, and by the Open Content Alliance in digitizing the collection of the world's biggest libraries and make it accessible for free via the internet also helps in this effort. However, it is not enough in the sense that, only works which copyright has expired is freely readable, while those which copyright has not expired can only be partially read. Project Gutenberg does the similar thing but minus recent copyrighted works. The Open Access initiative attempts to do the similar thing for academic journals, but not for the kind of work that layman readers would understand. Wikipedia's articles also help a great deal, but when compared to great books, still feels somewhat fragmented for someone who wish to learn thoroughly and holistically.
Thus, though we can understand and respect the good intention of the copyright system to create a win-win situation for the stakeholders of humanity's education enterprise, it is not enough, in terms of speed and distribution range. In mathemathical jargon, it is (still) necessary but insufficient in solving the educational equation.
So, what's the better solution?
Here, we propose that the content of these most important works, be released digitally under a free-to-use license such as the Creative Commons licenses. This does not imply that publishers must stop publishing and distributing the traditional way. It also does not imply that we must do so for all intellectual works. No, but only for, let's say, around 100 to 300 of them that would serve as a foundation for the kind of education our world desperately needs.
Thankfully,
wise people of our of our time sets the precedents for others to
follow. One of them is our very own WiserEarth founder, Paul Hawken,
with his Natural Capitalism (2000). Next is Lester Brown with his Eco-Economy(2001), Plan B: Rescuing a Planet Under Stress and a Civilization in Trouble (2003), Plan B 2.0 (2006). And the third is the people of the International Religious Foundation with their World Scripture: A Comparative Anthology of Sacred Texts (1991).
Along
with the sales of the medium (in this case, book), they also release a
digital version of the content (in PDF or HTML) free for everyone to
download and read. Though they may not be rated amongst the most
important works of our time, they're highly important and addresses
some of the most urgent issues of our time: the restructuring of our
economic system, the environmental crisis, and religious fundamentalism.
For the wisdom that rhymes, Sarah McLachlan's World on Fire
sets a commendable example, both through the quality of her work, and
through it's public release for everyone to see and listen, and then
act upon (donate money or do something good). BigPicture TV
also sets a good example of releasing talks and interviews video of
some of the wisest people living today, for free on their website.
It is important to note that these works are recent and actual, not the kind which copyright has expired (prior to 1930). In doing so, they augment the strict commercial copyright system with a wiser way of disseminating knowledge and wisdom. This is so because the former approach somewhat 'confine' the content in the medium and make them available only so far as the physical distribution network goes and only for those with enough money to buy, while the latter liberate the content via a democratic medium which increasingly become widespread and affordable for the world's majority: the digital medium of cyberspace. It is also important to note that the tools to participate in the digital world and economy, like the One Laptop Per Child project and Asus Eee PC is increasingly becoming eaffordable. Internet connectivity cost is also decreasing worldwide.
In short, those people put wings on the wisdom they synthesized, and let it fly around the world not only through traditional distribution routes, but also through the cyberspace to enlighten minds, hearts and actions, as widely and as quickly as possible. Their action sets example for others to follow, and this group is dedicated to accelerating and multiplying this act of liberating wisdom.
What will we do?
First, we shall find a way to determine the most important works, say 100~300 of them, that represents the whole range of issues and solutions that are must-learn for people who wish to change the world and their lives for the better and to make it more just and more sustainable. This would employ the wisdom of crowds, and WiserEarth provides the gathering place for just the right kind of crowd.
Second, we shall find a way to set free the content of these works for everyone to use for free. The Creative Commons with their range of licenses would be more than enough to solve the legal part of the equation. We must however find smarter ways in solving the financial part of the equation--of how to support the work done by authors and publishers, because they are the backbone of high-quality creative and enlightening endeavours. A kind of global fund similar to those that exist to produce and disseminate malaria and AIDS medicine comes in mind. But other alternatives are thinkable.
The primary target
of this effort would be excellent works that is old enough and maybe
out-of-print but still within the copyright effective term (say, from
the 1960s to the 1980s). These are the kind of works that are still
highly relevant to the dynamics of our time such as Rachel Carson's Silent Spring (1962) and E.F. Shumacher's Small is Beautiful (1973). The next goal would be to liberate newer and more relevant works, such as Thomas Homer-Dixon's The Upside of Down (2006), Worldchanging.com's book Worldchanging: A User's Guide for the 21st Century (2006), or Paul Hawken's Blessed Unrest (2007).
Though
books will be our primary target in the near future, further ahead or
simultaneously, multimedia works in the form of photographs (like the
image of Earth first seen from outer space or the collapse of the Berlin wall), educational movies (most probably documentaries, but not limited to it, such as This is What Democracy Looks Like and the End of Suburbia), spirit-uplifting songs, along with their video clips, and educational podcasts (including audiobooks such as those at Librivox, Project Gutenberg Audio and Open Culture, but broadened to include recent copyrighted works) will be our target.
Third, we shall organize these works into a learning resource pool accessible by anyone, so that every person who wish to educate themselves have instant access to the knowledge and wisdom they wish to emulate in their lives. WiserEarth is perfect for this role, as a repository of wisdom and a virtual learning space and community. A condensed version of the issues and resources categorized in WiserEarth's Area of Focus accompanied by the resources Wings for Wisdom envisioned to set free, would be a perfect match for an introduction course in creating a just and sustainable world.
The distribution method can mimic or learn from the highly successful example of the open-source software world's Ubuntu Linux which ships the installation CD for free to any country in the world with their ShipIt initiative, as internet connectivity--needed to download the large installation files--is still very expensive and not affordable for the world's majority. Or when connectivity price becomes affordable enough and the speed becomes fast enough for the world's majority, we can simply use services like YouTube and WiserEarth upcoming "upload files"/"file-hosting" feature.
Your part
Wings for Wisdom thus aims to put wings in the wisdom
synthesized from our tumultuous history by the noblest human beings so
they are free to enlighten all of humanity in the hope of winning the
race between education and catastrophe.
If you resonate with
this idea, help us succeed in this effort by refining and clarifying
this idea, and make it come true one step at a time by doing the
following actions:
Join Wings for Wisdom @
http://www.wiserearth.org/group/wings_for_wisdom/
Improve, refine or make detailed suggestion to the idea of Wings for Wisdom @
Brainstormings #1 : What do you think of Wings for Wisdom?
(The latest discussion results would be reflected in this article)
Start making a list of book recommendations @
Name 10 Books that Wings for Wisdom Should Set Free
(Read the first post for a guide in making the list)
Or simply tell this idea to your book-lover friends.
Comments (1 - 6 of 6)
|
Hello Cop,
While I too hope that you're wrong!... unfortunately, you're correct! Not much has happened to turn the idea into a reality.
I started that group in my early days joining WiserEarth in the hope of attracting enough people and energy to push it forward toward reality, but I found that there's much work to be done to make the WiserEarth soil more fertile so an idea like Wings for Wisdom can grow fruits. So, I switched my effort to making WiserEarth a more lively place and have since been happily occupied, especially with my being a WiserEarth staff recently. Guess it's time to revisit the idea. So thank you for stopping by with your kind words and constructive comment!
I'm glad to know that releasing your books in digital for free has substantially increase your readership and brought you the gratification you seek. I have to check further your site and books. Looks like an awesome 'wisdom' collection!
Regarding the "Google vs US Authors Guild" situation, I was aware of it to some extent but thanks to you, I now know the details. So, let's discuss your comments:
So what are the implications of this for a possible "Wings of Wisdom" project? 1. Let's reconsider the project's purpose. Is it really "to set free the most important intellectual works of our time from the confinement of copyright"? Or is it to make important books widely available free, or at low cost, regardless of their copyright status?
First and foremost, it's the latter. Eventually, hopefully not too distant in the future, the goal is to put those 'wisdom' under Creative Commons type of licensing scheme or the public domain. Why so? Simply put, it's not really free just by lengthening the chains! 2. How do we select the books? I don't have the answer, but would suggest that whatever person or group is doing it be open to all books that "would serve as a foundation for the kind of education our world desperately needs" even if they are not "classics." Is there an individual or group that has the necessary time and energy to put into this task?
There are numerous "list of great books", some of them I've come across while googling. But the basis of judgement does not necessarily fit into what Wings for Wisdom envisions. So, we probably will need to develop a set of criteria, a method of selection, and then people to execute. 3. The authors of many books whose copyright is still in force are now dead. In these cases the copyright and what to do about it is currently in the hands of the author's heirs. Heirs may not have the passion about these books' content, but presumably they would be interested in the potential revenue stream. So once we have the list from item 2 above, it will be necessary to track down the author or heirs and sell them on the idea of either giving the eBook editions away outright and/or joining the Google program. Again, who has the time and energy to do this?
No answer to this one too, unfortunately. We simply need more people.
4. All the books in question would not have to be housed in a wiserearth.org database. Some could be housed there, but as with many Wisdom Page resources, others could be accessed from the WiserEarth site via links to sites elsewhere, including the eventual Google book URLs.
This is correct. But having it on one place makes things easier for everyone. And WiserEarth can make that happen.
Now, a bit more on the "setting free" part relating to $$$: - What if we manage to find a way to pay for the release of each title into the public domain? - How much would be needed per title? - Would authors be willing to accept this option? - More specifically, would authors of cutting-edge/recent titles be willing to accept this option?
Got to go now. Looking forward to converse more with you Cop.
All my best, Bowo p.s. try using latest version of the Firefox browser if you keep experiencing problems with posting your comments. |
|
This was a comment by copmacdonald on my profile page, after he unsuccessfully tried posting it here:
This page was called to my attention by Anthony Judge, and I think the basic idea is terrific. I also note that the idea was first presented here back in 2007, the comments are at least a year old, and so I assume that not much has happened to turn the idea into a reality. Please correct me if I'm wrong — as I hope I am!
Here I'd like to share a few thoughts about approaches for making Wings of Wisdom, or something like it, actually happen.
First, the situation that writers face, using the example I know best. In the 1980s I came to the conclusion that what we need, both personally and globally, is much more of that then out-of-fashion quality called WISDOM. In the early 1990s I wrote two books on the subject (Toward Wisdom and Getting a Life), and in 1995 started "The Wisdom Page --- A site devoted to wisdom resources," now at www.wisdompage.com. In 2004 another book of mine was published, Matters of Consequence, a book intended to help us "envision both an optimized personal life and a world that works for everyone, and empowers us to do what needs to be done to create them." We authors write for two reasons: make $$$, and share our close-to-the heart ideas and perspectives with others. Some books achieve best-seller status and stay in print forever, continuing to make money during the period of copyright for the author or the author's heirs. I have managed to keep my own books in print, but in recent years sales were not great, and at some point my focus shifted to that second reason for writing. A couple of years ago I started giving my books away as screen-read-only Acrobat eBooks (info at http://www.wisdompage.com/ebooksinfo.html). Whereas sales of the paper-and-ink editions had dropped to 100 books a year or less, annual downloads of the eBooks have been in the thousands for each title, and for Matters of Consequence the number has consistently topped 20,000. Very gratifying. The money wasn't there, and still isn't. But a significant level readership IS there.
Enter today the almost-here reality of freely available electronic books AND a money stream to authors or their copyright-holding heirs. The Google situation mentioned in the proposal piece above describes the situation as it was in 2007. But in the past few weeks there have been dramatic new developments. Some time ago the US Authors Guild (and others) launched a class-action suit against Google to get compensation for the unauthorized digitizing of copyrighted books. That suit has just resulted in a most interesting settlement, agreed to by both Google and the Authors Guild, and awaiting the court's stamp of approval. Full details can be found at http://www.googlebooksettlement.com/ and the more detailed Notice at http://www.googlebooksettlement.com/notice.html. In short:
1. Google will be selling subscriptions to an electronic Books database, selling online access to books, and getting related advertising revenues.
2. Copyright owners have the right to determine whether and to what extent Google may use their works. They can, for example, set the online access price for a book.
3. And "63% of the revenues earned from Google's sale of subscriptions to an electronic Books database, sale of online access to Books, advertising revenues and other commercial uses" go to the rights-holder.
4. Google is also going to make provision for free public access. At "Libraries and Elsewhere: Google will provide on request, a 'Public Access Service' for free through a computer terminal at each public library building... The Public Access service will provide the same access to books as Google offers in the institutional subscriptions, except that users will not be able to copy/paste or annotate any portions of a book."
Personally, I have signed up to make my eBooks available under this program while still continuing to give away free the screen-read-only editions from my Wisdom Page website.
So what are the implications of this for a possible "Wings of Wisdom" project?
1. Let's reconsider the project's purpose. Is it really "to set free the most important intellectual works of our time from the confinement of copyright"? Or is it to make important books widely available free, or at low cost, regardless of their copyright status?
2. How do we select the books? I don't have the answer, but would suggest that whatever person or group is doing it be open to all books that "would serve as a foundation for the kind of education our world desperately needs" even if they are not "classics." Is there an individual or group that has the necessary time and energy to put into this task?
3. The authors of many books whose copyright is still in force are now dead. In these cases the copyright and what to do about it is currently in the hands of the author's heirs. Heirs may not have the passion about these books' content, but presumably they would be interested in the potential revenue stream. So once we have the list from item 2 above, it will be necessary to track down the author or heirs and sell them on the idea of either giving the eBook editions away outright and/or joining the Google program. Again, who has the time and energy to do this?
4. All the books in question would not have to be housed in a wiserearth.org database. Some could be housed there, but as with many Wisdom Page resources, others could be accessed from the WiserEarth site via links to sites elsewhere, including the eventual Google book URLs.
I hope that at least some of this is helpful, and might stir action in support of this basically great idea! If I had the time, I'd get involved myself. Sadly, I don't. |
|
I like what you have to say in your Wings for Wisdom group about copyrights, as I think our planet can progress to a different kind of "ownership" over intellectual works. Most of the world's greatest thoughts and books are limited in its reach due to the price thats on it, and as you say, our planet may not have enough time to wait. If only we saw our current or most common kind of copyright as a model that can be improved, rather than as perfect.
|
|
Wibowo, I like the way you think. This is a practical idea with low cost and tremendous benefit.
|
|
i thhink this is a great idea wibowo... i'll try and do my part by making recommendations for "the list"
|



Many thanks, bowo, for putting my comment up. I have used Firefox to sign in this time, and I hope this comment "takes."
My life is quite full these days, but I will be joining this group and will participate to the extent that time permits. I think what you are trying to accomplish is important — the challenge is to find ways of making it happen.
I agree with your comment "There are numerous "list of great books", some of them I've come across while googling. But the basis of judgement does not necessarily fit into what Wings for Wisdom envisions. So, we probably will need to develop a set of criteria, a method of selection, and then people to execute." One approach would be to get people to nominate books to be added to the list, but I guess your original request for suggestions didn't get too far. Any thoughts about how to publicize The Wings for Wisdom idea and make that request more effectively?
I agree that totally free is best, and maybe some copyright holders would be open to a one payment buyout of their rights, but I suspect that most would like to keep the copyright, because that keeps future options open to them, and make some edition (such as a screen-read-only eBook) available either free or in anticipation of a modest income stream. To me, the most important thing is having the books available on line to read sooner rather than later. I suspect that the transition to totally free, coupled with a suitable way of compensating authors, is going to be quite a while in coming.
In any event, it would be great to find ways of getting this project off the ground.
All the best,
Cop